Book Review: Can Democracy Survive Global Capitalism? by Robert Kuttner
This book pulls no punches, as Robert Kuttner identifies the guilty parties in the ongoing global heist from the non-rich to the rich. Kuttner even criticizes Thomas Piketty on some points—from a progressive perspective! Here you will find comprehensive documented details showing how business as usual continues, but not in the beneficial way the cheerleaders of the current practices of capitalism would have you believe.
Kuttner goes a little further than other writers who’ve addressed the problem of government capture by the financial oligarchy (frankly fascism), in that he emphatically prescribes remedies that are primarily political (and not just regulatory). Political transformation is the only way to remove the discrepancy between current government trends of tax cuts for the rich (with reductions in social services, environmental protection, and infrastructure) and consistent public opinion polling indicating preference for freedom from debt that involves universal health care, public education, improved transportation systems, sound ecological practices, and mitigation of extreme inequality.
Effecting such political transformation involves reduction in gerrymandering (or better yet, ranked-choice voting), including workers on corporate boards, and increasing voter participation from its current abysmal levels. (The US Senate remains an enduring non-democratic institution, which was a compromise between the original 13 states in 1787—that situation has long since evolved, and we will have to address the difficult question of apportionment in the Senate if the US is to ever have a truly representative government.) Regardless of the structure of the Senate, voter apathy is a major failure in politics as all levels that must be corrected.
Removing undue influence in elections is a different and looming challenge since the Citizens United decision, which opened the floodgates for all persons (or entities) to exercise their 1st Amendment rights of free speech—as long as you have the money to spend on exorbitant advertising and promotion costs (hint: that’s not most of us). Kuttner highlights the critical distinction between a one-person-one-vote system and one-dollar-one-vote system—unfortunately, in practical respects we’re currently operating under the latter arrangement. This influence-money goes to manipulate people to vote for candidates and initiatives, based on voters’ perceived needs as indicated by data analytics. On the surface, persuasion based on public perception is what political campaigns are all about—but when a critical mass of voters is disengaged and only peripherally paying attention, slight of hand logic and visceral manipulation carry outsized influence. With the vast majority of voters in TL;DR mode regarding politics, a communications means short of wonk level is needed to reach most people on critical issues.
Internationally, Kuttner addresses trans-national rules and norms that formalize private equity leeching—these must be thrown into full reverse. Purchased companies should be nurtured and operated productively, not cannibalized for investor profit. One can already hear the protests to this assertion: “But that’s how the system operates!”—that’s true, and it must stop! We need a system in which investors have no incentive to cannibalize the economy’s underpinnings in order to prosper.
Humans are social animals, who thrive only when we cooperate fairly with one another—Kuttner demonstrates why government, finance, industry, and labor must all be socially responsible in everything they do and demand. Enforced rules (legal or societal) are appropriate to ensure that is the case. A socially responsible tax structure (which we currently do not have) also would go a long way toward this end. Recognizing the humanity of those who are not seen as humans (in the eyes of different and often opposing groups) is an essential element to the cure—this is a reciprocal requirement, from which no one is exempt.
After all its proven-false claims of optimal prosperity, it is actually laissez-faire that is the road to serfdom. Socially responsible Keynesianism is a better road—let’s make the requisite political transformation in order to take it.
—