Live Laugh Love: The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made

Book Review: Live Laugh Love: The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made
by Kristin Kobes Du Mez

The subtitle identifies the main topic of discussion, with the main title soundly mocking the seductive pitch made to the many who were drawn into the life-depressing culture described in this book. Du Mez states that she wrote Live Laugh Love for men as well as women, observing that usually there were blank looks of non-recognition from the men at meetings in which she mentioned the topics addressed here—with women nodding knowingly. This raising of public awareness alone is a public service, as the lives and actions chronicled in this book have had an outsized adverse effect on society at large. The author describes the methods of 20th and 21st Century neoliberal charlatans who subordinated their Christian faith to that of unfettered capitalism and opposition to New Deal type assistance, plying to full effect the old false bromide that socialism is authoritarianism—pot meet kettle; theocratic autocracy required its followers to adhere to their leader’s economic interests over the Gospel message, errantly leading this obedient voting bloc to help produce the catastrophic societal effects seen over the past 40 years.

Among those catastrophic effects is the unconscionable oppression of women (and also some men). The descriptions in this book of real world actions by some church leaders including rape and other abuse reveal a revulsive white nationalist parallel with the Epstein files. Du Mez describes at length the related contradictions in purity culture developed for control of its adherents—the incompatible demands of purity obedience ran counter to the concurrent promotion of sex and material values considered necessary in advertising to sell products. For example, Miley Cyrus was in church purity culture during her early youth. The truncated careers of popular singers such as Anita Bryant and Amy Grant were due primarily to their challenging the hierarchy—an unforgivable sin in the world of theocratic autocracy. For those who miss Anita Bryant singing about the Florida Sunshine Tree (before she went on her anti-gay path), it’s informative to know that she personally held no ill will toward gay people—she assereted that their humanity was common with everyone.

Throughout the over 200 years of holiness sect activities presented in this book, several common threads are apparent through to our contemporary time—the most salient one is the clear divergence from the faith of the Apostolic era, and its replacement with unnecessary human control over others. Prayer often tracked closer to pagan practices in which they appealed to God for their personal desires—not too divergent from the ancient Romans or Greeks appealing to the gods for victory over their enemies, in which deities are treated more like vending machines or distractions to keep the public in submission rather than sentient entities with agency of their own. In a form of twisted irony the prayer attitude of some of these persons, along with the movements and organizations they launched, confused their own personal ambitions with the will of God.

The author illuminates this confusion between good and evil in recounting the progression from 20th Century adaptation of Communist recruitment methods for fundamentalist membership growth to 21st Century protection of church leaders who sexually assaulted their members. Du Mez describes methods such as using triangle groups of three people—two collaborating and the other the mark for indoctrination. Others invoke Seven Mountains Dominionism in justifying supporting Trump and others who exhibit un-Christian behavior but support the advancement of white Christian nationalism. This unloving personal attitude is further advanced by the concurrent fusion of faith requirements with neoliberal economics supporting exploitive capitalism and blame the victim ideology—your failure is yours alone and the fault of nothing else. The reference to their groups as cells by some of the operatives in these actions provides telling context. These events laid the groundwork for the white Christian nationalism that was prominent in the January 6 assault on the Capitol.

Far from focusing on wholesome holiness, the numerous examples of real people and some influential works of fiction described in this book present a coherent picture across the decades of worldly ambition dressed up in spiritual wrapping—the Bible admonishes against this deceptive attitude and behavior. Although the author primarily addresses activity targeting middle class white women, the effects of domineering authoritarianism have also reached outside white culture as this false doctrine becomes an illicit net of ensnarement that blurs faith, economics, and faux patriotism imposing obligations to those who set themselves up as leaders. What Du Mez chronicles in this book is the toxic snake oil of patriarchy, white supremacy, and violent religious nationalism that looks, walks, smells, and quacks like a self righteous cult scam. In addition to necessary full accountability for the perpetrators, we can and must also engage in sincere nuanced conversation to help all affected people outside and inside that world attain their own voice and human agency—as an effective counter to authoritarian impulses.